2 mixed reviews from hollywood reporter and variety
http://www.hollywoodreporter.com/hr/film/reviews/article_display.jsp?&rid=8465
http://www.variety.com/review/VE1117932223.html?categoryid=31&cs=1
josephc feared about heavy handiness from Zwick...it's seems that he was right.
the 2 reviews seems to like dicaprio and hounsou ;)
josephc- 11-30-2006
Yeah, really. I never felt that this film was exactly in oscar territory, like most other Zwick films (Glory was the one true exception for me, although Courage Under Fire wasn't bad, either). It looks like it will be at least worth a look, though, if only for the 2 lead actors. I love that both reviews give DiCaprio and Hounsou a nice sheen, if nothing else. I think that even though BD may not be a totally successful film in many ways (even, perhaps, at the B.O. I fear), it will hopefully help to at least boost Leo's other performance more into the spotlight. Hope, hope!!! The problem is that these award things are just getting way out of whack and turning totally silly in the process. I long for the days when there were maybe a couple meaningful critics awards and the oscars were the big event (without all the hoopla over fashion and sideshow nonsense).
Abstract- 11-30-2006
yapi, thanks for those reviews and lena for the Premiere one which I'd seen before elsewhere. josephc, yeah, I agree with what you've said there, about Zwick and his movies, the box office prospects and oscars. It's still hard to tell with only a handful of reviews, but just from these it seems this movie isn't going to cut it but Hounsou's and Leo's performances rise about the material. As far as Oscar noms for Leo, I'm a bit fearful now that he's gonna get squeezed out. But in the long run, meaning the future, it might actually bode well for Leo if that were to happen because then he'll have the sympathy factor in the future.It's possible I guess that he might be nom'd for supporting in TD and he has more of a chance to win that category this year than as a lead.
Abstract- 11-30-2006
They had a screening in NY today - pics
http://www.wireimage.com/GalleryListing.asp?navtyp=gls====248160&nbc1=1#
http://editorial.gettyimages.com/
Courtney- 12-01-2006
Screen Daily Review
Dir: Edward Zwick. US. 2006. 138mins.
A well-written, well-acted and provocative political action thriller, Edward Zwick’s Blood Diamond provokes its audience into thinking about the impact of diamond lust on the Third World. But its relentlessly realistic depiction of contemporary African warfare - and the way diamond smuggling funds it - is so horrific that it could be hard-pushed to be regarded as broad Friday night multiplex entertainment, despite featuring Leonardo DiCaprio.
Zwick has crafted several classily produced big-star movies about conflict past and present, such as The Last Samurai (2003, $457m globally), although that starred Tom Cruise and valued visual opulence above strong narrative. For better commercial comparisons, look towards Zwick’s The Siege (1998, about domestic terrorism, $116m worldwide) and Courage Under Fire (1996, about the first Iraq War, $100 worldwide), as well as Ridley Scott's Black Hawk Down (2001, $173m worldwide), another contemporary African warfare movie.
Blood Diamond could rival returns for Scott’s feature, especially given DiCaprio’s renewed profile following the recent The Departed. Broad upscale audiences may respond if the first major Hollywood production to address the diamond trade’s dirty side draws enough related news coverage. Certainly it will outpace lower-budget, less action-orientated features that have covered genocide in Africa, such as Hotel Rwanda (2004, which took $23.5m of its $33.6m worldwide gross from the US) and The Last King Of Scotland (2006), which are more character studies than adventure yarns.
Rolling out in the US on Dec 8, Blood Diamond is released in major international markets – where films starring DiCaprio usually take the balance of their box-office – in January and early February.
The film opens in Sierra Leone in 1999, during a brutal civil war in which thuggish rebels lop off the hands of children as a terror tactic. Roguish Danny Archer (DiCaprio) sneaks rebel-mined diamonds out of the country into Liberia, then on to a diamond company in London that stores them in a vault so as to control the market. Streetwise and world-weary, Archer knows the dangers of his trade all too well: in America diamonds mean bling bling, but in Africa they only cause bling bang.
Captured in the Sierra Leonese capital Freetown and jailed, Archer overhears that fellow inmate Solomon Vandy (Hounsou) is hiding a huge, pinkish diamond he discovered while forced to work for the rebels.
On release the two men form a reluctant alliance to locate the stone, Archer for its potential profit, Solomon in order to secure the release of his family from a refugee camp. Meanwhile, a muckraking journalist/photographer (Connelly) attaches herself to the pair and develops a relationship with Danny.
Edward Zwick studied Sorious Samura's documentary Cry Freetown – about the conflict in Sierra Leone – before he began shooting Blood Diamond and the grim depiction of violence evidenced here is shatteringly, exhaustingly naturalistic.
During the battle/slaughter scenes rockets are fired at low-level close-range targets with frightening results. The rebels, including their child soldiers, cruise around in vehicles like stoned-out zombies, fitted out with bizarre costumes, blaring radios and guns.
In the past Hollywood has been accused of romanticising the Third World in its portrayals of life – but it is something that Zwick has studiously avoided here. Certainly Blood Diamond has more narrative complexity and character development than the likes of Black Hawk Down, especially in how it expresses its political ideas. Yet the violence occurs so frequently and reliably that it eventually starts to acquire a rhythmic intensity not dissimilar to Ridley Scott’s feature.
Leonardo DiCaprio, in his second fine performance this year after The Departed, is all stubble and believable southern African accent. He carries Blood Diamond as a sly, treacherous, even furiously dangerous, amoral man who slowly grows a conscience. At the same time his character is fully formed enough to be calm, reflective, noble and flirtatiously charming when called for. Such charm is especially on display in his relationship with Jennifer Connelly, with who DiCaprio shows good chemistry, although her part is relatively one-dimensional in its definition.
With his shaven head and deep-voiced gravity, Djimon Hounsou acquits himself well – he may be an outside shot for supporting actor awards consideration – but Charles Leavitt's otherwise-astute screenplay sometimes renders him too noble for his circumstances. Elsewhere Michael Sheen - Tony Blair in The Queen – has an amusing cameo as the London diamond rep.
Photography – the film was mainly shot in Mozambique – is fast paced, as if the camera is darting around to avoid being blown up. Cinematographer Eduardo Serra contrasts the ramshackle, squalid crowdedness of urban areas with the beautiful vistas and horizons of the forested countryside, while a dusty refugee camp resembles a prison colony on the moon.
The drama is underscored by James Newton Howard's inspiring and mournful score, which mixes orchestral music with African choral voicehttp://www.screendaily.com/story.asp?storyid=28792&r=true
skydog- 12-02-2006
BD Reviews Thanks for the reviews everyone.
Love the last one, Courtney.
Everything from the cast and cinematography to the music score sounds incredible.
Saw some pix and news about the screening in NYC yesterday.
Thanks for posting a few here, Abstract
arnzilla- 12-02-2006
Ebert & Roeper just aired. Roeper said BD "deserves an Oscar nomination for best picture" and that it's "one of the best pictures of the year."
josephc- 12-02-2006
Fascinating about Roeper. I don't usually trust him too much, though! I notice on-the-web bloggers are on a tear for this one, however! Most seem to hate it. I think the main problem is mixing mainstream violent action pix B.S. where the heroes seem to always dodge the bullet with serious tragic material - i.e., the civil war in San Leone, people with limbs hacked off, "real" reality stuff - in a way that doesn't settle too well and the script doesn't seem to help. It doesn't help that most of them HATE ED ZWICK. I don't think the actors come off badly, though. Most seem to leave them out of it.
ArtReborn- 12-02-2006
I think most critics will rave about this film actually. Bloggers can be idiots. And from what I've seen so far, I wouldn't be surprised if this film does indeed get a best pic nom.
josephc- 12-02-2006
Kris Tapley has finally weighed in with a review on his blog Incontention.com. He clearly doesn't care much for the film giving it 2 stars (he also gives The Good German 2 stars), but interestingly, he does give kudos to DiCaprio saying that he's the one sort of saving grace of the movie. He didn't like Hounsou much, however, and didn't really mention Connelly at all. At least Leo is getting decent mention for it. Makes me want to give it a look at least.
Peanut80- 12-02-2006
Another BD review...very complimentary of DiCaprio....
**No spoilers ***
http://www.smart-popcorn.com/reviews/1489/
margot122- 12-02-2006
Thanks Peanut
virgomoon- 12-02-2006
Bling Bang BIG THANKS for all the reviews here.
I'm in 'catch up mode' tonight & I've lost track of all the great reviews I've read on this thread.
I LOVE the whole look & feel of BD.
I watch HBO's First Look last night over & over & over!
This is gonna be a very emotional movie.
Great music, great landscapes...
I LOVE the scenes between Danny & Maddy.
Just my opinion but I find Connelly much more appealing than Vera Farmiga.
And I find Connelly's Maddy a more likeable character than Farmiga's Madolyn.
Yeah...I know. They're 2 completely different movies.
Unfortunately, no sneak previews in my area tonight.
So I'm anxiously waiting to see BD next week. 8)
Abstract- 12-03-2006
Roeper gives it a thumbs up and the guest critic Peter Sagal who writes for some Tampa paper gave it thumbs up also. The segment is on tomorrow in some places Dec 3)
Forumer™ is Voted #1 Free Forum Hosting provider
Build your own community today with the largest message board hosting company.